CSA Roundup
I sent off the final payment for our 2009 CSA the other day (late, because I am full of forgetfulness and fail). Overall, the farm share–our first and, I’m almost certain, not our last–was a really delightful experiment. I loved getting my giant green shopping bag home every week, unloading everything onto the kitchen table and imagining all the dinners I might make with the haul. I loved the tiny, sweet strawberries and the floppy bunches of dill and the chance to make kohlrabi fries. I loved our handsome farmer and the sweet girl who checked my name off the list at pickup time. And I especially loved the bread share. Even if my ass did not.
Still, especially as we moved into the colder months and I wound up with twenty pounds of squash and kale and onions every week, it occurred to me more than once since June that a CSA–even a half share–isn’t particularly compatible with the way Tom and I live now. It was too much food, first of all. Even if we stayed home and cooked every night–which we basically never do–I’d still wind up with veg left over at the end of the week, a green bunch of something liquefying in my fridge. I gave away a lot of zucchini and lettuce and cabbage, and even though it made me popular at work and happy to share what we had, the CSA wasn’t exactly a cheap proposition–it was frustrating to feel so perpetually wasteful.
The cost was an issue in other ways, too. Our pickups tended to be really veg-heavy, and while that was awesome in theory, it also meant that I spent all of July and August walking past the farmer’s market fighting peach and plum envy because I had a crisper full of really expensive chard at home. And that’s when I was there to pick it up: this past summer, my schedule was so wonky that making sure somebody was there on Tuesdays between 3 and 6 to haul everything home became a project unto itself. Tom was more or less willing to go until the day he forgot the reusable bags and, he grumbled, “the woman yelled at me for polluting the environment!”
None of this is to say that I’d never do a CSA again. Quite the opposite, actually–I love the whole idea of being a part of an enterprise like this, and I’d absolutely recommend it to anybody who asked. But I think I’ll probably wait a few years before I do another round myself–’til we’re more settled, have more money–and can bear to look at another butternut squash.
AbbieBabble
January 20, 2010 @ 12:45 pm
“peach and plum envy” describes exactly why, though I fully support the IDEA of a CSA, I don’t want to join one. Going to the farmer’s market and buying those things that look absolutely delicious brings so much joy to my spring, summer and autumn weekends, I’m hesitant sign up for anything that takes those choices away.
summer
January 20, 2010 @ 3:00 pm
yes! this is exactly what i’ve been wanting to hear- real feedback! i am in love with the idea of a CSA, but have been wondering if it would be as lovely (full of fresh fruit) as i think. and i wasn’t sure about the economic effect either.
now i know the ups and downs of it. thank you so much!
kimtb
January 20, 2010 @ 4:53 pm
Oh, I am so there with you. We have done CSAs twice, and loved it at first. But it was the chard that put me over the top. It was great for experimenting and all, but I also missed our Farmer’s Market. I do think it’s awesome to support the small farmers….so my plan is to do it for a season every other year or so. Maybe I will do it this year, and then trade with you next year!
Susie
January 20, 2010 @ 6:19 pm
I had the same problem with CSA. Well, that and the fact that the person who most often eats with me hates 99% of all vegetables. Sigh. Farmer’s Markets for me.
marisa
January 21, 2010 @ 2:41 am
thanks for sharing this… i’ve been thinking about a CSA but had some reservations. i think i’ll try our local farmer’s market first.
stumbled on your blog somehow. lovely!